"Western parents are concerned about their children's psyches," Chua writes. "Chinese parents aren't. They assume strength, not fragility, and as a result they behave very differently.... That's why the solution to substandard performance is always to excoriate, punish, and shame the child. The Chinese parent believes that their child will be strong enough to take the shaming and to improve from it."
Source: http://shine.yahoo.com/parenting/a
re-chinese-parents-really-the-best-paren
ts-2438574.html
Good God, I thought it was some ancient military way of bringing up kids or something. I understand if it's just basically being firm with discipline, but the story seems closer to emotional abuse. Saying hurtful words and throwing back a card into your child's face for the sake of their own 'betterment' so that they can grow above it?! =____= What sort of purpose does that serve? So that your child will feel inadequate and never good enough so that they will keep trying harder? And have your child believe that their worth is in their achievements and they must be perfect, nothing less? And that it's ok for people to be hurtful towards them, as long as it is for 'their own sake'?
I think the only time kids can improve from that sort of horrible treatment is that if they fight AGAINST it, and not accept it. It's like how I read about kids in abusive families, those that accept abusive treatment feel it's alright, and become abusers themselves. Those that rise above it become very smart and successful, because they KNOW it's not right. But to use abuse as a way to raise kids? C'mon, this is a bit too much.
And apparently this woman's style of raising kids is coming out as a 'Chinese' parenting style for Western readers? =______= Gosh, I hope readers are not ignorant enough to think that this book represents the whole Chinese community.
I think the only good thing about knowing the existence of this book is how I DO NOT want to raise kids.
Ending it with a good response from one of the readers:
As an elementary school teacher, I’ve seen both extremes of the parenting spectrum, from the militant to the permissive. I’ve taught children who were raised in a manner similar to Chua’s, and while they succeeded academically, they were often rather stunted socially. They didn’t know how to “be children” and had difficulty relating to and interacting with the other kids. They were also completely unable to handle any sort of perceived failures, as they had been raised to believe that their entire identity and worth lay in their achievements. They expected themselves to be perfect in every way, which is a shame, as such expectations can only result in crushing disappointment.
That being said, the children of permissive parents I’ve taught have fared no better. They are often completely unmotivated to work at anything, as they know their parents will “love them no matter what”. It’s disheartening to see kids fail to meet their true potential, and even more disheartening to see that they don’t care.
In conclusion, I have to say that the most successful, well-adjusted students I’ve had over the years are those who are parented from a balanced perspective. They are encouraged to meet their potential, but not made to feel worthless in instances where they fall short.